Skip to main content

Table 2 Comparative study of 3D cell culture over animal models

From: Hydrogel based tissue engineering and its future applications in personalized disease modeling and regenerative therapy

Parameter

3D cell culture (organoid)

Animal model

References

Cost

Low

Expensive

[13, 16, 17]

Immunogenic response

Incorporation of immunogenic components under research

The response occurs in normal animal models however immunodeficient models lack such responses

[13, 17]

Vascularization

Not present

Reflect to in vivo

[13, 17]

Ethical concerns

No ethical issues because no animal testing is required. Only the use of animal serum raises concerns for animal welfare and human biosafety

Ethical concerns required to be addressed

[13]

Experimental complexity

Less complex

Higher organisms are used therefore high complexity

[13, 17]

Human in vivo imitation

Imitate the source tissue or organ

Does not imitate due to variation at the genetic level

[13, 17]

Genetic expression

Reflective to humans

Differ from humans

[13]

Cell microenvironment

Lack microenvironment, therefore, scaffolds used

Present naturally

[16]

Reproducibility

Low since scaffolds are used

Not satisfactory

[13, 17]