Skip to main content

Table 7 Residual effect of cinnamon essential oil formulations of on survival of Culex pipiens larvae

From: Synthesis and efficacy of cinnamon oil formulations and their sustainable release against common house mosquito larvae

 

Cinnamon ordinary

Cinnamon nanoemulsion

Post 24 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 48

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 72 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 96 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 120 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 144 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 24 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 48

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 72 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 96 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 120 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Post 144 h

Mean ± 

Std. Error

Ethyl alcohol 70%

2 ± .2a

.4 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.2 ± .2a

.4 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

.8 ± .2a

Delta 3.5ug/L

20.0 ± .0c

20.0 ± .0e

20.0 ± .0e

20.0 ± .0c

20.0 ± .0b

16.2 ± .4b

20.0 ± .0b

20.0 ± .0d1

20.0 ± .0d

20.0 ± .0b

20.0 ± .0c

16.2 ± .4c

1000 ug/

20.0 ± .0c

20.0 ± .0e

15.8 ± .6d

2.6 ± .5b

1.0 ± .3a

1.0 ± .3a

20.0 ± .0b

20.0 ± .0d

20.0 ± .0d

19.4 ± .4b

9.6 ± .5b

1.0 ± .3a

500 ug/ ml

20.0 ± .0c

17.8 ± .4d

5.0 ± .3c

1.0 ± .3b

1.0 ± .3a

.6 ± .2a

20.0 ± .0b

20.0 ± .0d

15.4 ± .5c

1.0 ± .3a

1.0 ± .3a

1.0 ± .3a

250 ug/ml

20.0 ± .0c

9.2 ± .4c

2.0 ± .4b

1.4 ± .2b

1.0 ± .3a

1.0 ± .3a

20.0 ± .0b

16.4 ± .2c

7.2 ± .6b

1.4 ± .2a

1.2 ± .2a

1.0 ± .3a

125 ug/ml

16.8 ± .4b

1.4 ± .2b

1.2 ± .2a

.8 ± .4b

.6 ± .2a

.6 ± .2a

20.0 ± .0b

2.8 ± .4b

1.4 ± .2a

1.0 ± .3a

1.0 ± .3a

.0 ± .0a

  1. Superscript of the same letter in cells of the same column indicates a non-significant effect compared to the control. Superscript of different letters in cells of the same column indicates a significant effect compared to the control (P ≤ 0. 05)